Dealing with a bad high school coach can be extremely frustrating for student athletes. Coaches play a critical role in shaping the skills, motivation, and enjoyment of their players. When coaches lack proper skills or behave unprofessionally, it can negatively impact the entire team.

If you’re short on time, here’s a quick answer to your question: Document all instances of improper behavior from the coach and present the information to school administrators to build a case for dismissal or discipline.

In this comprehensive guide, we will cover various strategies you can use to address concerns with a problematic high school coach, ranging from speaking directly with the coach to seeking their removal if the situation cannot be resolved.

Understand the Specific Issues with the Coach

When dealing with a bad high school coach, it’s important to first understand the specific issues at hand. By observing and documenting concerning behaviors, you can gather evidence to support your claims.

This could include instances of verbal or physical abuse, favoritism, lack of communication, or poor coaching techniques. Keep a record of dates, times, and details of any incidents that raise red flags. Having concrete evidence will strengthen your case when addressing the issue.

Observe and document concerning behaviors

One way to understand the specific issues with the coach is to closely observe their behaviors. Take note of any instances where the coach displays favoritism towards certain players, belittles or humiliates athletes, or fails to provide proper instruction or guidance.

Documenting these behaviors will help you build a case against the coach and provide evidence of their misconduct.

Identify core problems impacting players and team performance

In addition to observing concerning behaviors, it’s important to identify the core problems that are impacting the players and the team’s performance. Are there communication issues between the coach and the players? Is the coach neglecting to develop proper strategies or techniques?

By identifying these core problems, you can better understand the impact the coach is having on the team and address these issues directly.

Consult with other players and parents to understand their experiences and concerns

Another valuable step in understanding the specific issues with the coach is to consult with other players and parents. Talk to your teammates and their parents to get a broader perspective on their experiences and concerns.

This can help you identify patterns of misconduct or unfair treatment that may be occurring. By uniting with others who share similar concerns, you can work together to address the issue and seek a resolution.


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Luke Tank (@luketankproductions)

Have a Direct Conversation

When dealing with a bad high school coach, it is essential to address the issue directly.  Avoiding the problem will only allow it to persist and potentially worsen. By having a candid conversation, you can express your concerns and work towards finding a resolution.

Schedule a face-to-face meeting in private

Choose a suitable time and place to meet with your coach privately. This will create a comfortable environment for both parties to discuss the issues at hand. By meeting face-to-face, you can ensure effective communication and avoid any misunderstandings that may arise from written or electronic communication.

Present your concerns objectively and focus on solutions

When discussing your concerns with your coach, it is important to remain calm and objective. Clearly articulate the specific issues you are facing, providing examples if necessary. Instead of dwelling on the negatives, focus on potential solutions that can improve the coaching experience for everyone involved.

Be open to coach’s perspective and clarifying questions

During the conversation, be open to hearing your coach’s perspective. They may have insights or reasons behind their actions that you were not aware of. Encourage them to ask clarifying questions to ensure a clear understanding of your concerns.

This open dialogue can lead to a more fruitful discussion and potential resolution.

Agree to clear expectations moving forward and schedule a follow-up

At the end of the conversation, it is crucial to establish clear expectations moving forward. Discuss any changes or improvements that both parties agree upon. This ensures that everyone is on the same page and working towards a positive outcome.

Additionally, schedule a follow-up meeting to assess progress and address any remaining concerns.

Remember, approaching the situation with a willingness to find a resolution is key. By having a direct conversation, you are taking the first step towards improving the coaching experience and creating a positive environment for all athletes involved.

Involve School Administrators

If you are dealing with a bad high school coach, one of the most effective steps you can take is to involve the school administrators. By bringing the issue to their attention, you can ensure that proper action is taken to address the problem and create a positive learning environment for all students.

Share documentation and outcome of direct conversation

Before approaching the school administrators, it is essential to gather evidence of the coach’s inappropriate behavior or ineffective coaching methods. This may include documenting specific incidents, conversations, or any negative impact on the students’ performance or well-being.

By presenting this evidence, you provide a clear picture of the situation and increase the chances of a favorable outcome.

Furthermore, if you have already had a direct conversation with the coach and it did not result in any improvement, make sure to share the details of that discussion as well. This will demonstrate that you have attempted to resolve the issue directly and have valid concerns that need to be addressed.

Highlight potential impact on students and school reputation

When discussing the issue with school administrators, emphasize the potential impact that the coach’s behavior or coaching style may have on the students and the reputation of the school. Highlight how it can affect the students’ physical and emotional well-being, as well as their academic performance and overall experience in high school.

Additionally, mention any incidents or feedback from other students, parents, or community members that may have raised concerns about the coach. This helps to paint a broader picture of the issue and reinforces the need for intervention.

Ask for disciplinary action or dismissal if no improvement

If the coach’s behavior or performance does not improve even after bringing it to the attention of the administrators, it is crucial to request disciplinary action or, in severe cases, dismissal. Your primary concern should be the well-being and development of the students, and if the coach is hindering that, it is necessary to take more decisive steps.

Ensure that your request for disciplinary action or dismissal is backed by the evidence you have gathered and the negative impact observed on the students. This will strengthen your case and increase the likelihood of the administrators taking appropriate action.

Threaten to escalate to school board or state athletic association if needed

If the school administrators fail to address the issue satisfactorily, you may consider escalating the matter to the school board or even the state athletic association. Threatening to take this step can often prompt administrators to take the issue more seriously and expedite the resolution process.

However, it is essential to use this as a last resort and only if you genuinely believe that the coach’s behavior or coaching methods pose a significant threat to the students’ well-being and the integrity of the school’s athletic program.

Remember, involving school administrators is a crucial step in getting rid of a bad high school coach. By presenting evidence, highlighting potential impact, requesting disciplinary action, and threatening escalation if necessary, you can ensure that the issue is taken seriously and resolved in the best interest of the students and the school.

File a Formal Complaint

Consult school policy and state laws for complaint process

If you find yourself dealing with a bad high school coach, the first step towards resolving the issue is to consult the school policy and state laws regarding the complaint process. Each school may have different procedures in place for handling complaints, so it’s important to familiarize yourself with these guidelines.

Additionally, understanding the state laws can provide you with valuable information on your rights as a student-athlete.

Document all examples of improper behavior, with dates and witness accounts

To strengthen your case against a bad high school coach, it is essential to document all instances of improper behavior. Keep a detailed record of each incident, noting the date, time, and location. It is also important to gather witness accounts from teammates or other individuals who have witnessed the coach’s inappropriate actions.

This documentation will serve as crucial evidence when filing a formal complaint.

Submit copies of complaint to all relevant authorities

Once you have compiled your evidence and written a formal complaint, it is crucial to submit copies to all relevant authorities. This includes school administrators, the athletic director, and any other governing bodies that oversee the coach’s conduct.

By doing so, you ensure that your complaint is heard by the appropriate individuals who have the power to take action.

Remember, when filing a formal complaint, it’s important to remain professional and objective. Stick to the facts and avoid personal attacks. By following the proper procedures and providing sufficient evidence, you increase your chances of effectively addressing the issue and ultimately getting rid of a bad high school coach.

Transfer Schools or Quit the Team

If you find yourself with a bad high school coach, one option to consider is transferring to another school district. This may be a viable solution if you have the opportunity to do so. Transferring to a different school can provide a fresh start and the chance to be part of a team with a more positive and supportive coaching staff.

It’s important to research and visit potential schools to ensure they have a coaching environment that aligns with your goals and values.

Switch teams or quit team as a last resort

If transferring schools is not an option, you may want to consider switching teams within your current school or, as a last resort, quitting the team altogether. Speak with the athletic director or a school counselor to explore the possibility of joining a different team, especially if there are multiple teams for the same sport.

This could provide a chance to work with a different coach who may be a better fit for you.

Quitting the team should only be considered as a last resort. It’s important to weigh the potential negative impact of leaving the team against the benefits of removing yourself from a toxic coaching environment.

Consider discussing your concerns with a trusted adult, such as a parent or mentor, to help you make an informed decision.


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Logan Gehman (@whitespot_photography)

Consider legal action for negligence or emotional distress

In extreme cases where a coach’s behavior is truly egregious, it may be appropriate to consider legal action. This could include pursuing a lawsuit for negligence or emotional distress. However, it’s important to consult with a legal professional to understand the specific laws and regulations in your jurisdiction.

They can guide you on the potential merits of your case and the appropriate steps to take.

Remember, taking legal action should be a last resort and should not be done without careful consideration. It’s always advisable to exhaust all other options, such as transferring schools or switching teams, before pursuing legal action.


Having an ineffective or problematic high school coach can seriously impact a team’s performance and students’ well-being. While removing a coach should not be taken lightly, players and parents do have options to address substantiated concerns.

By taking a measured approach – from direct communication to formal escalation if needed – students can advocate for a more positive team environment and protect their athletic development and future prospects.

Similar Posts