Choosing between a prep school and a public high school is an important decision that can shape your child’s future. With rising competitiveness for college admissions, many parents consider sending their kids to private preparatory schools which boast smaller classes, rigorous academics, and high matriculation rates to top universities.

If you’re short on time, here’s a quick answer to your question: Prep schools generally offer more personalized attention, stricter discipline, competitive athletics, and esteemed college counselors, while public schools provide a more diverse student body and community integration at a lower cost.

In this comprehensive 3000 word guide, we will compare all aspects of prep and high schools including costs, academics, extracurriculars, college preparation, admissions, culture, and more. We’ll also look at pros and cons of each as you make this big choice for your teenager.

Background on Prep and Public High Schools

What is a Prep School?

A prep school, short for preparatory school, is a type of private secondary school that prepares students for college or university education. These schools are known for their rigorous academic programs, small class sizes, and challenging curriculum.

Prep schools often have a strong focus on college preparation, offering advanced courses, specialized programs, and extracurricular activities to enhance the students’ academic and personal growth.

Prep schools also tend to have a selective admissions process, requiring students to go through an application and interview process. They often have higher tuition fees compared to public high schools, but they may offer scholarships and financial aid to make education accessible to a wider range of students.

What is a Public High School?

A public high school is a government-funded educational institution that provides secondary education to students within a specific district or area. Public high schools are open to all students regardless of their academic abilities or financial background.

They offer a comprehensive curriculum that meets state educational standards and prepares students for various post-secondary pathways, including college, vocational training, or entering the workforce.

Public high schools are funded by local, state, and federal taxes, which means that tuition fees are typically lower or non-existent compared to private schools. They serve a diverse student population and often have larger class sizes than prep schools.

Public schools follow a standardized admissions process, with enrollment based on residency within the school district.

Key Differences at a Glance

Prep School Public High School
Private institution Government-funded institution
Rigorous academic programs Comprehensive curriculum
Selective admissions process Enrollment based on residency
Higher tuition fees Lower or non-existent tuition fees
Smaller class sizes Larger class sizes
Strong emphasis on college preparation Various post-secondary pathways
It’s important to note that while these are general characteristics of prep schools and public high schools, there can be variations and exceptions within each category. Additionally, the quality of education and opportunities available can vary greatly between individual schools, regardless of their classification.

If you want to learn more about prep schools, you can visit Boarding School Review, which provides detailed information and reviews of various prep schools across the United States.

To discover more about public high schools, you can explore the official website of your local school district or visit National Center for Education Statistics, where you can find data and reports on public schools nationwide.

Comparing Academics


When it comes to curriculum, prep schools and high schools have some key differences. Prep schools often offer a more rigorous and comprehensive curriculum, focusing on college preparation. They may offer a wider range of advanced placement (AP) courses and elective options compared to traditional high schools.

High schools, on the other hand, typically follow a standardized curriculum mandated by the state or district. While high schools also offer AP courses, the range may be more limited compared to prep schools.

According to a study conducted by National Center for Education Statistics, prep school students tend to have higher scores on standardized tests, suggesting that their curriculum may be more academically challenging.

Class Sizes

Class sizes can vary between prep schools and high schools. Prep schools often pride themselves on smaller class sizes, which allow for more individualized attention and personalized instruction. On the other hand, public high schools tend to have larger class sizes due to the larger student population.

However, it’s important to note that not all high schools have large class sizes, as some may have smaller class sizes in certain specialized programs.

A study published in the American Educational Research Journal found that students in smaller class sizes tend to have higher academic achievement and better engagement with the material. This suggests that the smaller class sizes often found in prep schools can be advantageous for students.

Teacher Quality

The quality of teachers can vary between prep schools and high schools. Prep schools often have a more competitive hiring process and may require their teachers to have advanced degrees or specialized training.

This can result in a higher concentration of experienced and highly qualified teachers in prep schools.

In contrast, high schools may have a more diverse range of teacher qualifications. While many high school teachers hold advanced degrees, there may also be a mix of teachers who have alternative certifications or are in the process of obtaining their teaching credentials.

It’s important to note that teacher quality can vary within both prep schools and high schools. The presence of highly qualified teachers is important for student success, regardless of the type of school.

Academic Support

Both prep schools and high schools typically offer academic support services to their students. However, the level and extent of these services may differ. Prep schools often have dedicated academic support centers, where students can receive individualized tutoring, study skills training, and assistance with college applications.

In high schools, academic support services may be more limited and may vary from school to school. Some high schools may have tutoring programs or study groups, but the availability and extent of these services may depend on the resources of the school.

Availability of Advanced Courses

Prep schools often have a wider range of advanced courses available compared to high schools. This includes advanced placement (AP) courses, International Baccalaureate (IB) programs, and specialized courses in subjects like STEM or the arts.

In high schools, the availability of advanced courses can vary. While many high schools offer AP courses, the range of subjects and availability may be more limited compared to prep schools. Additionally, not all high schools offer IB programs or specialized courses.

It’s worth noting that the availability of advanced courses can impact college admissions, as many colleges and universities value a challenging course load. However, it’s important to consider the individual needs and goals of the student when evaluating the importance of advanced courses.

Examining Extracurriculars


When it comes to sports, both prep schools and high schools offer a wide range of options for students to participate in. However, one key difference is the level of competitiveness. Prep schools often have highly competitive sports programs, with teams that frequently compete at the state or even national level.

These schools often have top-notch facilities and coaches who are experts in their respective sports. On the other hand, while high schools also have sports teams, the level of competition may not be as intense, and the focus may be more on participation and fostering a sense of teamwork.

Clubs & Activities

Both prep schools and high schools provide numerous opportunities for students to get involved in clubs and activities. These extracurriculars can range from academic clubs, such as debate or robotics, to special interest clubs, like photography or cooking.

In prep schools, these clubs often have a more specialized focus and may offer more advanced opportunities for students. High schools, on the other hand, may have a wider variety of clubs available, catering to the diverse interests of their student body.

Regardless of the setting, participating in clubs and activities can help students develop valuable skills, explore their interests, and make new friends.

Arts & Music Programs

Both prep schools and high schools recognize the importance of arts and music education. These programs provide students with opportunities to express their creativity and develop their artistic talents.

Prep schools often have well-established arts and music programs, with state-of-the-art facilities and experienced instructors. These schools may offer specialized classes, such as advanced art or music theory, and provide students with the chance to showcase their talents through performances or exhibitions.

High schools also offer arts and music programs, although the resources and opportunities may vary depending on the school. However, regardless of the setting, participating in arts and music can be a fulfilling and enriching experience for students.

College Preparation

Preparing for college is an important aspect of a student’s education, whether they attend a prep school or a traditional high school. Both types of schools offer resources and support to help students navigate the college application process and increase their chances of getting into their desired colleges.

College Counseling

Both prep schools and high schools typically have dedicated college counseling departments to assist students in their college preparation journey. These departments provide guidance on course selection, extracurricular activities, and help students create a well-rounded college application.

Counselors also offer one-on-one meetings to discuss college preferences, review application essays, and provide advice on the college selection process.

Prep schools often have smaller class sizes, allowing for more personalized attention from college counselors. This can be beneficial for students who need additional support or have specific goals in mind.

High schools, on the other hand, may have larger student populations and fewer college counselors, but they still strive to provide valuable guidance and resources to their students.

Test Prep

Standardized tests, such as the SAT and ACT, play a significant role in the college application process. Both prep schools and high schools recognize the importance of test scores and offer resources to help students prepare for these exams.

Prep schools often have dedicated test prep courses and resources that focus on strategies, practice exams, and personalized instruction. These schools may have higher average test scores due to their emphasis on test preparation.

High schools, while still offering test prep resources, may have a more general approach to test preparation, as they have a broader student population to cater to.

College Matriculation Rates

One of the key indicators of a school’s success in college preparation is its college matriculation rate. This rate represents the percentage of students from a particular school who go on to attend college immediately after graduation.

Prep schools often have high college matriculation rates, with many of their students gaining acceptance into prestigious universities. These schools have a strong academic focus and rigorous curriculum, which helps prepare students for the demands of college.

High schools, while they may have lower college matriculation rates compared to prep schools, still have a significant number of students who go on to attend college.

It’s important to note that college matriculation rates can vary widely between schools, and individual student performance and effort also play a crucial role in college acceptance.

For more information on college preparation and the college application process, visit websites such as and

Admissions and Costs

Admissions Selectivity

When it comes to admissions selectivity, prep schools and high schools differ in their approach. Prep schools, also known as independent schools, often have a rigorous admissions process that involves interviews, standardized tests, and academic evaluations.

They typically have limited spots available and are highly selective in choosing their students. On the other hand, high schools generally have an open admissions policy, accepting students based on their residency and age requirements.

While some high schools may have selective programs within the school, the overall admissions process is less competitive compared to prep schools.

Tuition and Fees

One of the major differences between prep schools and high schools is the cost. Prep schools are known for their higher tuition and fees compared to public and private high schools. The cost of attending a prep school can vary significantly depending on the school’s location, reputation, and facilities.

According to a study by the National Association of Independent Schools, the average tuition for a day school was $22,000 per year, while the average boarding school tuition was around $55,000 per year.

In contrast, public high schools are funded by taxpayers and typically have little to no tuition fees, while private high schools may have lower tuition fees compared to prep schools.

Financial Aid

While the cost of attending a prep school may be higher, many schools offer financial aid programs to make education more accessible to students from diverse backgrounds. These programs aim to provide assistance to families who may not be able to afford the full tuition.

Financial aid packages can include scholarships, grants, and work-study opportunities. It is important to note that the availability and eligibility criteria for financial aid can vary from school to school.

Families interested in sending their child to a prep school should research and inquire about the financial aid options available at each institution.

Culture and Environment

Student Body Diversity

In terms of student body diversity, prep schools and high schools can vary significantly. Prep schools often attract students from all over the country and even from different parts of the world. This diverse student body brings a unique blend of cultures, perspectives, and experiences to the school community.

High schools, on the other hand, tend to have a more localized student body, drawing primarily from the surrounding community. This can lead to a less diverse environment in terms of cultural backgrounds and experiences.

While both types of schools strive to create inclusive environments, prep schools often place a stronger emphasis on fostering diversity and cultural understanding. They may offer programs, clubs, and events that celebrate and promote different cultures, providing students with opportunities to learn and appreciate diversity.

High schools, on the other hand, may have a more limited range of cultural experiences available within the student body.

Rules and Discipline

When it comes to rules and discipline, prep schools and high schools also have their differences. Prep schools tend to have stricter rules and regulations compared to high schools. This can include stricter dress codes, curfews, and more structured daily routines.

Prep schools often have a stronger focus on discipline and personal responsibility, aiming to prepare students for the rigors of college and professional life.

High schools, on the other hand, may have more lenient rules and a less rigid disciplinary approach. While they still enforce important rules for the safety and well-being of students, high schools may allow for more individual expression and autonomy.

This can create a more relaxed atmosphere where students have more freedom to explore their interests and express themselves.

Boarding vs Day School Options

One of the major distinctions between prep schools and high schools is the option of boarding versus day school. Prep schools often offer boarding facilities, allowing students to live on campus during the academic year.

This provides students with a unique opportunity to immerse themselves in a residential community, fostering independence and self-reliance. Boarding schools often provide a structured environment with designated study hours, extracurricular activities, and support systems for students living away from home.

High schools, on the other hand, primarily offer day school options where students commute to and from home each day. This allows students to maintain a closer connection to their families and local communities.

While high schools may also offer extracurricular activities and support systems, the overall experience is typically more focused on academics and social interactions during school hours.

Pros and Cons

Advantages of Prep Schools

Prep schools offer several advantages compared to traditional high schools. One major advantage is the emphasis on academic rigor and college preparation. Prep schools often have smaller class sizes, allowing for more individualized attention from teachers.

This can lead to better academic performance and higher chances of getting into top-tier colleges and universities.

Another advantage of prep schools is the access to a wide range of extracurricular activities. These schools often have state-of-the-art facilities and offer a variety of sports, clubs, and arts programs.

This allows students to explore their interests and develop their talents outside of the classroom.

Furthermore, prep schools often have a strong sense of community and foster a supportive and competitive environment. This can create a sense of camaraderie among students and help them develop important social skills and networks that can benefit them later in life.

Disadvantages of Prep Schools

While prep schools offer many advantages, there are also some drawbacks to consider. One major disadvantage is the cost. Prep schools are typically private institutions and can be quite expensive. This might limit access to students from lower-income backgrounds who may not be able to afford the tuition fees.

Additionally, the competitive nature of prep schools can sometimes lead to high levels of stress and pressure among students. The rigorous academic expectations and intense competition can take a toll on students’ mental and emotional well-being.

Another potential drawback is the lack of diversity. Prep schools often have a reputation for being less diverse compared to public schools. This lack of diversity can limit students’ exposure to different cultures, perspectives, and experiences.

Benefits of Public Schools

Public schools also offer several benefits. One of the main advantages is the accessibility and affordability. Public schools are funded by the government and are free for all students to attend. This makes education more accessible to a wider range of students, regardless of their socioeconomic background.

Public schools also tend to have a more diverse student population, which can expose students to different cultures and backgrounds. This diversity can help foster tolerance, understanding, and empathy among students.

Furthermore, public schools often offer a wide range of extracurricular activities, although the variety may vary depending on the school district. These activities can provide students with opportunities for personal growth, leadership development, and the exploration of various interests.

Drawbacks of Public Schools

Despite the benefits, public schools also have some drawbacks. One disadvantage is the larger class sizes compared to prep schools. With larger class sizes, it can be more challenging for teachers to provide individualized attention to each student.

Another drawback is the potential for overcrowding. Public schools can sometimes be overwhelmed with a high number of students, which can result in limited resources and facilities.

Additionally, the curriculum in public schools may not always be as rigorous as in prep schools. This can impact the level of academic challenge and preparedness for college.

It’s important to note that the advantages and disadvantages mentioned above can vary from school to school. It’s crucial for parents and students to thoroughly research and consider their options before making a decision.


In conclusion, both prep and public schools can provide a high-quality education with motivated teachers and bright students. Prep schools offer prestigious academics and strong college placement services but require significant tuition fees.

Public schools deliver diverse student bodies and community integration for free, but may lack some personalized resources. Weigh your family priorities like costs, college goals, environment, and activities as you make this important decision.

Similar Posts